Rereading the Theory of Superiority in the Order of Caliphate and Its Consequences

Farmaniyan, Mahdi; Rashed, Abd Al-Reza

Rereading the Theory of Superiority in the Order of Caliphate and Its Consequences

Document Type : Original Article

Authors

¹ Associate Professor, Department of Theological Denominations, University of Religions and Denominations, Qom, Iran

² PhD Student in National Security Studies, University and Higher Institute of National Defense and Strategic Research, Tehran, Iran

Abstract

One of the basic characteristics of the Caliph and the Imam about which Muslims disagree is the need to be superior to other members of the community. Some Sunni scholars do not consider such a condition necessary for the Imam and believe it is permissible to give priority to the inferior. On the other hand, the Imami Shiites and some Sunnis, although they disagree on the criterion of superiority, regard superiority as a necessary condition for Imamate. Many Sunnis have considered it expedient to be silent about Imamate as much as possible while discussing the issue of superiority, and therefore, in later periods, in order to eradicate the root of conflict, they put forth "superiority in the order of caliphate". In this article, in addition to examining the evolution of superiority, its criteria such as knowledge, piety, courage, jihad and physical strength, based on verses and hadiths, are discussed, and the problem facing this theory is explained. For this reason, the Sunnis and even the three caliphs referred matters to the best, and preferred him over others. The most basic consequence of this theory is in the issue of "conflicts in narrations and judgments", and in this article, with a descriptive-analytical approach, the superiority of Imam and the theory of "superiority in the order of caliphate" and its consequences are scrutinized.

Keywords

20.1001.1.24234125.1400.7.20.4.3

Main Subjects

Rites, rules, ethics and spiritual teachings of Shi`a .

References

The Holy Qurān. n.d. Translated by Naser Makarem Shirazi, n.p: House of the Noble Quran.

Amini, Abd al-Hoseyn. 1977. Al-Ghadir fi al-Ketab wa al-Sonnah wa al-Adab, Beirut: Arabic Book House. [in Arabic]

Ashari, Abu al-Hasan. 1980. Maghalat al-Eslamiyin wa Ekhtelaf al-Mosallin (Islamists' Statements and Difference Between Worshipers), Germany: Frans Steiner. [in Arabic]

Baghelani, Abubakr. 1947. Al-Tamhid fi al-Radd ala al-Molhadah al-Motalah wa al-Rafezah wa al-Khawarej wa al-Motazelah, Cairo: Arab Thought House. [in Arabic]

Baghelani, Abubakr. 1994. Tamhid al-Awael wa Talkhis al-Dalael (Preparing the Beginnings and Summarizing the Reasons), Beirut: Cultural Books Institute. [in Arabic]

Bokhari, Mohammad ibn Esmail. 1981. Sahih al-Bokhari, Cairo: Thought House. [in Arabic]

Dinewari, Ibn Ghotaybah. 1990. Al-Emamah wa al-Siyasah (Imamate and Politics), Beirut: Al-Azwa House. [in Arabic]

Fakhr Razi, Mohammad ibn Omar. 1990. Tafsir al-Razi, Cairo: Thought House. [in Arabic]

Farahidi, Ahmad ibn Khalil. 1985. Al-Ayn, Qom: Al-Hejrah House. [in Arabic]

Fazel Meghdad, Meghdad ibn Abdollah. 1997. Al-Nafe Yawm al-Hashr fi Sharh Bab Hadi Ashar, Beirut: Al-Azwa House for Printing, Publishing and Distribution. [in Arabic]

Ganji, Mohammad ibn Yusof. n.d. Kefayah al-Taleb fi Managheb Ali ibn Abi Taleb (Self-sufficiency of Students in Virtues of Ali ibn Abi Talib), Tehran: Ahl al-Bayt Heritage Revival House. [in Arabic]

Ghazi, Abd al-Jabbar ibn Ahmad. 1961. Al-Moghni fi Abwab al-Tawhid wa al-Adl (Self-sufficiency in the Chapters of Unification & Justice), Egypt: Arab Company. [in Arabic]

Ghortobi, Mohammad ibn Ahmad. 1985. Al-Jame le Ahkam al-Quran (Collection of the Quranic Rules), Beirut: Heritage Revival House. [in Arabic]

Hakem Neyshaburi, Mohammad ibn Abdollah. 1998. Al-Mostadrak ala al-Sahihayn, Beirut: Knowledge House. [in Arabic]

Hamsi Razi, Sadid al-Din. 1992. Al-Monghez men al-Taghlid (Savior from Imitation), Qom: Islamic Publishing Institute. [in Arabic]

Helli, Jafar ibn Hasan. 1994. Al-Maslak fi Osul al-Din wa al-Resalah al-Mateiyah, Mashhad: Islamic Research Association. [in Arabic]

Heythami, Nur al-Din. 1988. Majma al-Zawaed (Collection of Extras), Beirut: Scientific Books House. [in Arabic]

Horr Aameli, Mohammad ibn Hasan. 1994. Wasael al-Shiah ila Tahsil Masael al-Shariah (The Means of the Shiites to Achieve the Issues of Sharia), Qom: Al al-Bayt Foundation. [in Arabic]

Ibn Abd al-Berr, Yusof ibn Abdollah. 1992. Al-Estiaab fi Marefah al-Ashab (Acquisition of the Knowledge on the Companions), Beirut: Al-Jayl House. [in Arabic]

Ibn Abi al-Hadid, Abu Hamed Abd al-Hamid. 1959. Sharh Nahj al-Balaghah (Explanation of Nahj al-Balaghah, n.p: Arab Books Revival House. [in Arabic]

Ibn al-Sabbagh Maleki Makki, Ali ibn Mohammad. 2001. Al-Fosul al-Mohemmah fi Marefah al-Aemmah (Important Chapters on Knowing Imams), Qom: Al-Hadith House for Printing and Publishing. [in Arabic]

Ibn Atham Kufi, Ahmad. 1991. Al-Fotuh, Beirut: Al-Azwa House. [in Arabic]

Ibn Atiyah, Moghatel. 1958. Motamar Olama Baghdad, Tehran: Islamic Book House. [in Arabic]

Ibn Hanbal, Ahmad. 1992. Mosnad al-Imam Ahmad ibn Hanbal, Beirut: Heritage Revival House. [in Arabic]

Ibn Manzur, Mohammad ibn Mokarram. 1985. Lesan al-Arab (Language of Arabs), Qom: Adab Publication. [in Arabic]

Ibn Nadim, Mohammad ibn Eshagh. n.d. Al-Fehrest, Beirut: Knowledge House. [in Arabic]

Ibn Sad, Mohammad. n.d. Al-Tabaghat al-Kobra, Beirut: Sader House. [in Arabic]

Ibn Shahr Ashub, Mohammad ibn Ali. 1957. Managheb Al Abi Taleb (Virtues of Abi Taleb's Family), Najaf: Al-Heydariyah Library. [in Arabic]

Iji, Ghazi Azod al-Din. 1997. Al-Mawaghef, Beirut: Al-Jayl House. [in Arabic]

Joweyni, Abd al-Malek ibn Abdollah. n.d. Al-Ershad ela Ghawate al-Adellah fi Osul al-Eteghad (Guide to Conclusive Evidence of the Principles of Belief), Beirut: Scientific Books House. [in Arabic]

Kharazmi, Mowaffagh ibn Ahmad. 1993. Managheb (Virtues), Qom: Islamic Publishing Institute. [in Arabic]

Koleyni, Mohammad ibn Yaghub. 1986. Osul al-Kafi, Tehran: Islamic Books House. In Arabic]

Labbaf, Ali. 2009. Daneshnameh Rawabet Siyasi Ali (AS) wa Kholafa (Encyclopedia of Political Relationships between Ali (AS) and the Caliphs), Tehran: Monir. [in Farsi]

Majlesi, Mohammad Bagher. 1983. Behar al-Anwar al-Jameah le Dorar al-Akhbar al-Aemah al-Athar (Oceans of Light, the Collection for Pearls of Narrations of the Infallible Imams), Beirut: Al-Wafa Institute. [in Arabic]

Mofid, Mohammad ibn Noman. 1994. Al-Ershad fi Marefah Hojajellah ala al-Ebad (Guide to Knowing the Representatives of God over the People), Beirut: Al-Mufid House for Printing, Publishing and Distribution. [in Arabic]

Mostanbet, Ahmad. 2009. Al-Ghatrah men Behar Managheb al-Nabi wa al-Etrah (The Drop from the Sea of Virtues of the Prophet and His Family), Qom: Almas. [in Arabic]

Mottaghi Hendi, Ala al-Din Ali al-Mottaghi ibn Hesam al-Din. 1989. Kanz al-Ommal fi Sonan al-Aghwal wa al-Afaal (The Treasure of Workers in the Traditions of Words and Deeds), Beirut: Al-Resalah Institute. [in Arabic]

Namazi Shahrudi, Ali. 1998. Mostadrak Safinah al-Behar, Qom: Islamic Publishing Foundation. [in Arabic]

Nobakhti, Hasan ibn Musa. 1984. Feragh al-Shiah (Shiite Denominations), Beirut: Al-Azwa House. [in Arabic]

Ragheb Esfahani, Hosayn ibn Mohammad. 1984. Mofradat Gharib al-Quran (Glossary of Quranic Terms), Qom: Book Publishing Office. [in Arabic]

Sadr, Seyyed Mohammad Bagher. 1990. Dorus fi Elm al-Osul (Lessons in the Science of the Principles of Jurisprudence), Beirut: Acquaintance House of Publications. [in Arabic]

Sadugh, Mohammad ibn Ali. 1984. Oyun Akhbar al-Reza (AS) (Selected Words of Imam Reza), Beirut: Al-Alamy Foundation for Publications. [in Arabic]

Sadugh, Mohammad ibn Ali. n.d. Man la Yahzoroh al-Faghih (The One Who Doesn’t Have Access to a Jurist), Qom: Qom Seminary Teachers Association. [in Arabic]

Samani, Mansur ibn Mohammad. 1998. Tafsir al-Samaani, Riyadh: Homeland Institute. [in Arabic]

Sanani, Abd al-Razzagh ibn Hammam. 1983. Al-Mosannaf, India: Scientific Assembly. [in Arabic]

Sharif Askari, Najm al-Din Jafar. 1961. Ali wa al-Kholafa (Ali and the Caliphs), Najaf: Al-Adab Library. [in Arabic]

Sharif Razi, Mohammad ibn Hosayn. 1986. Khasaes al-Aemmah (The Characteristics of the Imams), Mashhad: Astan Ghods Razavi. [in Arabic]

Tabarani, Soleyman ibn Ahmad. n.d. Al-Mojam al-Kabir (The Great Dictionary), Beirut: Arab Heritage Revival House. [in Arabic]

Tabari, Ahmad. n.d. Al-Riyaz al-Nazerah fi Managheb al-Asharah (Lush Gardens on the Virtues of the Ten), Beirut: Scientific Books House. [in Arabic]

Tabarsi, Fazl ibn Hasan. 1995. Majma al-Bayan fi Tafsir al-Quran (Collection of Statements on the Interpretation of the Quran), Beirut: Al-Alamy Foundation for Publications. [in Arabic]

Tabatabayi, Seyyed Mohammad Hoseyn. 1992. Al-Mizan fi Tafsir al-Quran (The Yardstick of the Interpretation of the Quran), Qom: Qom Seminary Teachers Association. [in Arabic]

Tusi, Mohammad ibn Hasan. 1989. Al-Tebyan fi Tafsir al-Quran (Clarification of the Quran Interpretation), Beirut: Arab Heritage Revival House. [in Arabic]

Yaghubi, Ahmad. n.d. Tarikh al-Yaghubi, Beirut: Sader House. [in Arabic]

Zarandi Hanafi, Mohammad. 1958. Nazm Dorar al-Semtayn, Beirut: Arab Heritage Revival House. [in Arabic]